The twinkling lights, cozy fires, and scent of pine might set the stage for cheer — but what if there’s something a little more sinister hiding beneath the tinsel? If you love your holidays with a side of suspense, Christmas mystery books offer the perfect mix of festive warmth and chilling intrigue. From snowbound mansions with secrets to small-town celebrations turned deadly, these stories wrap murder and mistletoe together in the most delightful way.

So, pour yourself a mug of hot cocoa, curl up under a blanket, and get ready to unwrap a few mysteries this holiday season — because nothing says “Merry Christmas” like a bit of murder under the mistletoe.

Disclosure: The FTC Disclosure Provision is a law that requires influencers to disclose when they are being paid to promote a product or service. So please know that if I'm not making money through affiliate links/sponsored content on the post you're currently reading, it's an oversight on my part and will be corrected soon. Read the full disclosure about all the legal stuff here.

Murder Mystery Novels to Enjoy This Holiday Season

Christmas Mystery Books on my TBR

• ASIN ‏ : ‎ B07HBCKKR2
• Publisher ‏ : ‎ Vinci Books
• Publication date ‏ : ‎ September 13, 2018
• Print length ‏ : ‎ 254 pages

Distanced by her children and determined not to spend another Christmas alone, Susan Belcroft books a stay at a ski resort, hoping to rekindle her sagging spirit.

With travel to the lodge interrupted by a sudden snowstorm, she and three other stranded drivers accept a seemingly kindhearted rescue, only to find themselves charged with theft.

The stakes increase when police find the accusers’ dead bodies.

No Gifts to Bring is an endearing cozy mystery of love and hope, intertwined with an engaging whodunnit. A young child with disabilities, a flamboyant singer, a handsome traveler, and an irritating private detective open Sue’s heart to the magic of Christmas. If you enjoy a touch of romance and an amateur sleuth who has an uncanny ability to make connections, you’ll love Kathleen McKee’s prequel to the Aspen Notch Mystery Series.

Mistletoe Malarkey (Shayla Murphy Mysteries Book 1) by Stella Bixby

Buy on Amazon - See on Goodreads

• ASIN ‏ : ‎ B09J3DMRTT
• Publisher ‏ : ‎ Ferry Tail Publishing LLC
• Publication date ‏ : ‎ December 7, 2021
• Print length ‏ : ‎ 222 pages

Seamus, a down-to-earth park ranger, has always been modest about his background. Living with three roommates and driving a trusty old pickup truck, he never gave Shayla any reason to suspect he was anything but ordinary.

Until they land in Ireland, and Shayla discovers he's practically Irish royalty.

The welcome is warm, but unexpected. The press descends, camera flashes ignite, and Shayla's previously hidden insecurities start to surface. A holiday that was meant to be filled with festive family fun now carries the weight of public scrutiny.

The getting-to-know-you dinner party sets the stage for a complicated holiday. An old flame, a mysterious uncle, and a whole town full of complex characters await Shayla. The table is set with rich Irish fare, traditional music, and sparkling conversation.

But the celebration takes a dark turn when a guest ends up dead.

Local law enforcement are quick to step in, urging Shayla to leave the matter to them. Her policing skills might be respected in the United States, but in Ireland, she's merely a visitor.

Shayla's instincts are sharp, and whether she seeks them or not, clues seem to find her at every turn. Despite warnings from the Gardaí and the tangled web of family dynamics, she can't shake her sense of duty to solve the case.

Set against the picturesque backdrop of a quaint Irish village, adorned with historic charm, this Christmas mystery unfolds with subtlety and suspense. Join Shayla as she navigates family traditions, new relationships, hidden agendas, and a murder that threatens to overshadow the joy of the season.

With a touch of romance, a hint of intrigue, and the authentic warmth of an Irish Christmas, this tale is a perfect fireside read. Embrace the season with this engaging holiday mystery, as Shayla proves that love, loyalty, and the pursuit of truth transcend borders.

King of Christmas A Choose Your Own Path Psychological Thriller by J.E. Rowney

Buy on Amazon - See on Goodreads

• ASIN ‏ : ‎ B0FTMV52YR
• Publisher ‏ : ‎ Little Fox Publishing
• Publication date ‏ : ‎ November 21, 2025
• Print length ‏ : ‎ 524 pages

Eight missing children. One urban legend. A town that stopped asking questions.

They call him the King of Christmas—a red-cloaked figure said to haunt Pine Hollow, taking children who’ve done wrong. Always on Christmas Eve. Always leaving behind a trail of footprints in the snow… and a single silver bell for every home that's lost a child.

In this unique psychological thriller book, you decide what Jenny does next.

KING OF CHRISTMAS is a uniquely immersive Choose Your Own Path psychological thriller where your decisions shape the story. Every choice matters. Some truths are buried deep. Some paths lead to justice. Others to regret.

Choose carefully. The King of Christmas is watching.

Christmas Mystery Books Recommended by Readers

"There's a great Slow Horses short story, 'Standing by the Wall', set at Christmas. Also, I'm rereading 'Small Things Like These' by Claire Keegan. So good. Oh, and I've just remembered John Banville's grim but fab 'Snow'." @AllisonPer323

"Christmas in Castleby by J M Simpson is a brilliant read 📚 🎄" @em_nightreader

"The Christmas Appeal - Janice Hallett. Also A Cornish Christmas Murder and The Cornish Christmas Pantomime Murder by Fiona Leitch. Denzel Meyrick’s historical mystery series. Set in 1950s Book 1 Murder at Holly House Book 2 The Christmas Stocking Murders Both good reads." @ProudHeadTeach1

"Mince Pies and Murders by J.R. Leigh" @PandaMum14

"Murder On The Christmas Express  and The Christmas Murder Game - Alexandra Benedict. The Christmas Appeal - Janice Hallett. Christmas Is Murder - Val McDermid. There are several by Agatha Christie too!" @DeborahS31

As the snow falls and the fairy lights twinkle, there’s nothing quite like getting lost in a story filled with secrets, surprises, and just a touch of Christmas magic. Christmas mystery books capture both the warmth of the season and the thrill of a good puzzle — perfect for those long winter evenings. So pull up a blanket, pour yourself a steaming mug of hot chocolate, and let a little festive intrigue keep you turning the pages until the very last clue is revealed.

Don’t forget to share your favourite Christmas mystery in the comments — after all, even the best detective loves a good recommendation.